Americas Best Value Inn St. Ignace

This hotel is frequently chosen for its convenient location near the ferry dock, making it a practical base for exploring the area. Its signature feature, the indoor pool and hot tub, often draws guests, providing a welcome amenity despite occasional maintenance issues. Many guests highlight the hotel's cleanliness and the friendly staff as consistent positives, even though the property itself is often described as dated. It serves as a good fit for value-conscious travelers and families seeking an affordable stay with recreational options. Overnight travelers and those on motorcycle tours also find it suitable for a no-frills stop. To enhance your experience, consider bringing your own breakfast items, as the provided options are often limited, and requesting an upper-floor room to minimize potential noise disturbances.

Facilities & Amenities
The hotel offers an indoor pool and hot tub, which are popular amenities, though the hot tub is frequently reported to have non-functioning jets, be cold, or have low water levels. The pool itself is generally described as heated and clean, but some guests noted issues with cloudiness or foam. Wi-Fi connectivity is a common point of frustration, often described as spotty, unstable, or slow, making internet access unreliable. While refrigerators are available in rooms and appreciated, the absence of an in-room microwave is a frequent complaint. Guests also noted that ice machines were often broken, and the laundry facilities were consistently out of order or closed for the season, causing significant inconvenience for those planning extended stays.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
Guest feedback on cleanliness is mixed; while many reviews commend the rooms as clean and well-maintained, others report issues such as stained carpets, dust on surfaces, hair in bathrooms, or sticky floors. The overall impression of the rooms is that they are dated and outdated, with some mentioning old furniture, cracking walls, or a general need for updates. Bed comfort receives varied comments, with some guests finding the beds comfortable and ensuring a good night's sleep, while others describe lumpy mattresses or feeling bed springs. Noise levels are a significant concern, with frequent complaints about noisy neighbors, sounds from upstairs guests, parking lot noise, and loud heating units, impacting the tranquility of the stay. Additionally, some bathrooms are noted for loose tiles, dirty showers, or mold.

Dining & Food Quality
The breakfast offered by the hotel consistently receives negative feedback, often described as pathetic, a joke, or woefully lacking. Guests frequently express disappointment with the minimal selection, which typically includes only toast, bagels, and pancakes from a machine, along with cereal (sometimes without milk) and coffee. There is a notable absence of hot food options such as eggs, sausage, or bacon, and fresh fruit or pastries are rarely available. Many reviews highlight that the limited items often run out quickly, especially if guests arrive later in the morning. The dining area is sometimes described as small and crowded, further detracting from the experience.

Location & Accessibility
The hotel's location is generally well-regarded, being conveniently situated close to the ferry dock for island access and within a short driving distance of downtown St. Ignace and local attractions. Guests appreciate the ease of reaching points of interest, with some noting it's a good base for exploring the wider area. While some reviews mention it's too far to walk to downtown, a free shuttle service to the island ferry is a valuable amenity. Parking is ample and well-lit, providing convenience for guests traveling by car. The hotel's position across from the water also offers pleasant views for some rooms.

Staff & Service
The staff at the hotel consistently receives high praise for their friendliness, helpfulness, and attentive service. Guests frequently highlight positive interactions with front desk personnel, who are described as polite, accommodating, and willing to assist with requests, including room changes or local information. The check-in process is often noted as quick and efficient. While housekeeping is typically provided upon request or after check-out due to staffing, guests found staff responsive in providing extra towels or other necessities. The overall sentiment is that the staff's positive demeanor significantly contributes to a more pleasant stay, despite some of the property's shortcomings.

Additional Information
Guests frequently note that the outdated property is in need of significant renovations, with many areas appearing worn or neglected. Common issues include door functionality, where doors may not close or latch properly without force, or have visible gaps. Some guests experienced poor cell service within the hotel, requiring reliance on the often unreliable Wi-Fi. There were isolated mentions of an unexpected tourist fee being added to the bill. While the hotel is generally considered a good value for money by some, others felt it was overpriced given its condition and the limited amenities. Guests should also be aware that noise from other guests or the parking lot can be a significant disturbance due to thin walls.