How payments to us affect ranking

from$113
See prices from 6 sites
See prices
Open Hearth Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge
Open Hearth Lodge

Good to know

  • Exceptional pet-friendly experience

    Dogs are treated like royalty with welcome baskets, in-room beds, and a dedicated dog wash area, making it a true home away from home for furry companions.

  • Tranquil setting with natural views

    Relax on a patio overlooking trees and open land, offering mesmerizing views and a peaceful escape, complemented by outdoor grilling facilities.

  • Spacious suites with whirlpools

    Indulge in select suites featuring a private whirlpool tub and fireplace, providing a luxurious and relaxing retreat within your room.

  • Interactive pancake machine breakfast

    Start your day with a complimentary continental breakfast featuring a fun conveyor pancake maker, alongside a variety of options and Door County coffee.

  • Inviting outdoor fire pits

    Gather around multiple gas fire pits, lit nightly, offering a cozy ambiance for socializing or relaxing under the stars amidst peaceful surroundings.

  • Convenient shuttle to Sister Bay

    Take advantage of the complimentary shuttle service to the Christmas market and downtown Sister Bay, offering easy access to local attractions.

This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.

About Open Hearth Lodge

The Open Hearth Lodge is located on 6 plus acres in Sister Bay, Door County, Wisconsin. The Lodge is Open all seasons. Continental Breakfast available daily. There is an indoor pool and whirlpool. Choose from standard rooms or suites. There is a laundry, as well as a fitness center with an infrared sauna available to guests. The walking, biking trail to downtown starts at the end of the driveway. This path also hooks in to the snow mobile trails in the winter.

Rooms

  • Lodge King Bed (No Pet)

    Lodge King Bed (No Pet)

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • A/C
  • Evergreen 2 Bedroom Suite (No Pets)

    Evergreen 2 Bedroom Suite (No Pets)

    • 1 2 King Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 8
    • 500 sq ft
    • A/C
  • Deluxe Double Room, Multiple Beds

    Deluxe Double Room, Multiple Beds

    • 1 2 Queen Beds and 1 Twin Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 6
    • 380 sq ft
    • A/C
  • Premium Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Jetted Tub

    Premium Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Jetted Tub

    • 1 1 King Bed and 1 Twin Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 5
    • 380 sq ft
    • A/C

Compare with similar stays

Selected stay

from$113
See prices from 6 sites
See prices

Similar stays

  • from$92
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices

  • from$148
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices

  • from$178
    See prices from 6 sites
    See prices

  • from$158
    See prices from 3 sites
    See prices

  • from$123
    See prices from 8 sites
    See prices

  • from$232
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices

  • from$185
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices

  • from$114
    See prices from 6 sites
    See prices

  • from$119
    See prices from 8 sites
    See prices

  • from$194
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices

Price trend

Based on average prices on trivago from the last 30 days
$332
$165
$0

二, 07/21/26

$268

三, 07/22/26

$254

四, 07/23/26

$263

五, 07/24/26

$331

六, 07/25/26

$332

日, 07/26/26

N/A

一, 07/27/26

$259

二, 07/28/26

$246

三, 07/29/26

$309

四, 07/30/26

$291

五, 07/31/26

$332

六, 08/01/26

N/A

日, 08/02/26

$236

一, 08/03/26

$264

二, 08/04/26

$235

三, 08/05/26

$252

四, 08/06/26

$249

五, 08/07/26

N/A

六, 08/08/26

N/A

日, 08/09/26

$246

一, 08/10/26

$239

二, 08/11/26

$250

三, 08/12/26

$253

四, 08/13/26

$249

五, 08/14/26

N/A

六, 08/15/26

N/A

日, 08/16/26

$244

一, 08/17/26

$255

二, 08/18/26

$258

三, 08/19/26

$241

四, 08/20/26

$248

五, 08/21/26

N/A

六, 08/22/26

N/A

日, 08/23/26

$266

一, 08/24/26

$265

二, 08/25/26

$265

三, 08/26/26

$240

四, 08/27/26

$241

五, 08/28/26

N/A

六, 08/29/26

N/A

日, 08/30/26

$233

一, 08/31/26

$230

二, 09/01/26

$232

三, 09/02/26

$232

四, 09/03/26

$221

五, 09/04/26

N/A

六, 09/05/26

N/A

日, 09/06/26

N/A

一, 09/07/26

$213

二, 09/08/26

N/A

三, 09/09/26

N/A

四, 09/10/26

N/A

五, 09/11/26

N/A

六, 09/12/26

N/A

Reviews

9.5
Excellent
based on 2,406 ratings from top 
sites

Review summary

Summarized by AI from 900+ reviews · Last updated: 29 May 2026

This hotel is a welcoming and cozy retreat, ideal for families, couples, and pet owners seeking a "home away from home" experience. Its prime location in the heart of Door County offers both peaceful seclusion and easy access to downtown Sister Bay, Ephraim, and various natural attractions. The property boasts an inviting indoor pool and hot tub, complemented by outdoor fire pits and a dedicated dog park. Guests consistently praise the friendly and accommodating staff and the delicious, ample breakfast offerings. For a truly comfortable stay, consider booking a room with a king-size bed for optimal support and relaxation.

Rated above average for Sister Bay

Guest reviews

Excellent93%
Very good5%
Good2%
Fair0%
Poor0%

Top amenities

  • WiFi in lobby
  • WiFi in rooms
  • Pool
  • Spa
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Gym

All amenities

Property amenities

  1. Business center
  2. Express check-in/check-out
  3. Elevator
  4. Gym
  5. Terrace
  6. Pet-friendly
  7. Non-smoking rooms
  8. Computer with internet
  9. Sun umbrellas
  10. Deck chairs
  11. Towels at the pool/beach
  12. Laundry service

Accessibility

  1. Wheelchair accessible
  2. Accessible parking

Wellness

  1. Sauna
  2. Hot tub

Room amenities

  1. Fireplace
  2. Bathtub
  3. Shower
  4. Ironing board
  5. Openable windows
  6. Television
  7. Hairdryer
  8. Central heating
  9. Air conditioning
  10. Radio
  11. Satellite TV
  12. Desk

Sports facilities

  1. Bowling
  2. Bike rental
  3. Golf course
  4. Fitness
  5. Minigolf
  6. Skiing
  7. Hiking trail
  8. Fishing

For children

  1. Playground
  2. Organized activities for kids

Hotel theme/type

  1. Eco-friendly hotel

Location

2669 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, 54234-9160, USA

Distance from Open Hearth Lodge

Sister Bay:1 miles

Anderson Store Museum:1.9 miles

Ephraim Historical Foundation:1.9 miles

Pioneer School:2.1 miles

Pioneer Cabin:2.1 miles

Historic Iverson House:2.2 miles

Door Community Auditorium:5.7 miles

Oil House:7.9 miles

Two-Seat Privy:7.9 miles

Peninsula Players Theatre:8.5 miles

Marquette Sawyer Regional Airport:81.7 miles

Explore nearby attractions

Property info

2669 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, 54234-9160, USA

Frequently Asked Questions about Open Hearth Lodge

  • Is there a pool area at Open Hearth Lodge?

    Yes, Open Hearth Lodge offers 1 pool area.

  • Are pets allowed at Open Hearth Lodge?

    Yes, Open Hearth Lodge has a pet policy that may vary based on the room type or availability. Please check with the hotel directly to learn about their pet policy.

  • Is parking available at Open Hearth Lodge?

    Yes, Open Hearth Lodge provides Accessible parking for guests.

  • What time is check-in and check-out at Open Hearth Lodge?

    Check-in at Open Hearth Lodge is available from: . Check-out time is by .

  • Where is Open Hearth Lodge located?

    Open Hearth Lodge is located at 2669 S Bay Shore Dr, 54234-9160, Sister Bay, USA.

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Among Top Rated Hotels in Sister Bay

  • Popular choice
    2 Stars
    Hotel
    Somerset Inn & Suites
    9.1Excellent (1,817 ratings)
    Ephraim, 1.4 miles to City center
    from$148
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices
  • 2 Stars
    Hotel
    Waterbury Inn
    9.0Excellent (951 ratings)
    Ephraim, 1.1 miles to City center
    from$214
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices
  • 3 Stars
    Hotel
    Edgewater Resort
    9.2Excellent (1,974 ratings)
    Ephraim, 0.2 miles to City center
    from$161
    See prices from 3 sites
    See prices
  • 2 Stars
    Hotel
    Pine Grove Resort
    8.9Excellent (1,327 ratings)
    Ephraim, 0.3 miles to City center
    from$182
    See prices from 6 sites
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    3 Stars
    Hotel
    Eagle Harbor Inn
    9.4Excellent (2,082 ratings)
    Ephraim, 0.4 miles to City center
    from$112
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    2 Stars
    Hotel
    Parkwood Lodge
    8.7Excellent (2,175 ratings)
    Fish Creek, 1.5 miles to City center
    from$123
    See prices from 8 sites
    See prices
  • 2 Stars
    Hotel
    Bay Breeze Resort
    9.4Excellent (1,264 ratings)
    Ephraim, 0.7 miles to City center
    from$147
    See prices from 6 sites
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    3 Stars
    Hotel
    Homestead Suites
    9.1Excellent (2,082 ratings)
    Fish Creek, 0.6 miles to City center
    from$92
    See prices from 7 sites
    See prices
  • 3 Stars
    Hotel
    Peninsula Park-View Resort
    8.7Excellent (585 ratings)
    Fish Creek, 2.7 miles to City center
    from$163
    See prices from 6 sites
    See prices

Other stays in Sister Bay

Popular hotel categories in Sister Bay

Destinations near Open Hearth Lodge

See all stays in Sister Bay