Sherwood Inn

This historic resort, nestled on the shores of Lake Joseph, offers a quintessential "old Muskoka" experience, making it a memorable destination for guests. Its signature feature is its stunning natural setting, providing breathtaking lake views and a tranquil atmosphere. The property is ideal for couples seeking a romantic getaway, families looking for outdoor activities, and nature lovers who appreciate hiking trails and water sports. Many guests choose this resort for special occasions like anniversaries and weddings, praising the dedicated event coordination. To enhance your stay, consider utilizing the complimentary watercraft for exploring the lake and be sure to enjoy the nightly fire pits for a cozy evening under the stars.

Facilities & Amenities
The resort offers a wide array of facilities catering to various interests, from a lovely sandy beach perfect for children to a range of complimentary water activities including kayaks, canoes, and paddleboards. Guests can also enjoy land-based options such as a tennis court, pickleball court, and extensive hiking trails suitable for snowshoeing in winter. A games room provides indoor entertainment, and nightly fire pits are a popular gathering spot. While some guests expressed a desire for more amenities like an outdoor hot pool, saunas, or a steam room, the existing offerings are generally well-received. The presence of an EV charger is a convenient addition for electric vehicle owners.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
Guest feedback on room comfort and cleanliness is varied, reflecting a mix of dated and updated accommodations. Many rooms are praised for being clean and comfortable, featuring amenities like a wood fireplace, jacuzzi tubs, and balconies with picturesque lake views. The beds are frequently described as comfortable, ensuring a restful sleep. However, some guests noted that certain rooms or cottages appear old and tired, with issues such as peeling paint, dirty carpets, or a lack of basic items like cups or bathroom hooks. Noise can occasionally be an issue, with mentions of sounds from adjacent rooms, the heating system, or a distant ice machine.

Dining & Food Quality
The resort's dining experience consistently receives high praise, with many guests highlighting the exceptional food quality and variety. The breakfast buffet is particularly popular, described as delicious, excellent, and offering a wide range of options, though some find it to be on the expensive side or note that food can be cool. Dinner at the on-site restaurants is frequently lauded for its delicious meals, including standout dishes like short ribs and lamb chops. The restaurant atmosphere is often described as cozy and inviting, with a beautiful dining room and a pleasant patio offering scenic views. While most experiences are positive, some guests reported slow service or limited menu availability during peak times.

Location & Accessibility
The resort's location is a significant draw, situated directly on Lake Joseph in the heart of Muskoka. This provides guests with stunning lake views and easy access to the water for various activities. It is conveniently close to charming towns like Port Carling and Bala, offering additional sightseeing and shopping opportunities. The property boasts well-maintained hiking trails that allow guests to explore the natural surroundings. While the location is generally praised for its tranquility and beauty, some guests noted that parking can be limited, especially during busy periods, and that the resort's layout includes a hill to reception, which might be challenging for guests with mobility concerns.

Staff & Service
The staff at the resort consistently receive high praise for their friendliness, helpfulness, and attentiveness. Guests frequently commend the team for their welcoming demeanor and willingness to go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. The check-in process is generally smooth and efficient, with staff accommodating late arrivals. Many reviews highlight the exceptional service provided in the restaurants and during special events, such as weddings, where the coordination and execution are described as flawless. While the majority of feedback is overwhelmingly positive, a few guests experienced instances of slow service in the lounge or perceived unfriendliness from some restaurant staff, though these appear to be isolated incidents.

Additional Information
Guests should be aware that the resort operates with a destination fee or amenity fee, which some find adds unexpectedly to the overall cost and is not always clearly explained during booking. The resort has a mixed reputation regarding its pet-friendly policy, with some guests noting it is accommodating while others were informed it is not. The property is known for its historic and quaint charm, offering a classic Muskoka experience. During power outages, the resort benefits from a backup generator, ensuring continued services. Guests also appreciate unique touches like the availability of DVDs to borrow and the option to purchase art for sale by local artists in the lobby.