Sugarloaf Lodge

17001 Overseas HighwayKey West33042USA
Serviced apartment
Show more hotels

About Sugarloaf Lodge

Sugarloaf Lodge is a family-owned, waterfront hotel and marina located in Sugarloaf Key, a world-class fishing area in the lower keys. The hotel offers complimentary boat dockage with each room.

All 31 rooms are waterfront and have a patio or balcony overlooking the secluded bay and its wild habitat of fish, birds and other wildlife. Rooms are non-smoking and feature air conditioning, a refrigerator and a flat-screen TV.

Sugarloaf Lodge offers free Wi-Fi in public areas and free parking. The full-service marina has bait and fishing supplies and can arrange charters and kayak rentals. The hotel has an outdoor pool and two tennis courts.

The Sugarloaf Tiki Bar is a favorite local spot for cocktails and views. Sugarloaf Pizza serves breakfast, lunch and dinner, and offers carry-out meals to eat on the beach.

The hotel and marina is located on the Overseas Highway, just 15 miles from Key West.


17001 Overseas Highway, Key West, FL, 33042, USA
Telephone: +1 3057453211 | Fax: +1 305 745 3389 | Official Homepage

Top amenities

  • Free WiFi in lobby
  • Free WiFi in rooms
  • Pool
  • Spa
  • Parking
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar
  • Gym

All amenities

Hotel facilities

  • Computer with internet
  • Deck chairs / Lounge chairs
  • Free WiFi in lobby
  • Hotel bar
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Parking garage
  • Restaurant
  • Terrace
  • WiFi in lobby

Room facilities

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathroom with bathtub
  • Bathroom with shower
  • Cable TV
  • Free WiFi in rooms
  • Television
  • WiFi in rooms


  • Accessible parking

Arrival / Departure

  • Check-in: 15:00
  • Check-out: 11:00

Positive Reviews

Great Tiki Bar

The Sugarloaf Tiki Bar is a favorite with locals and guests. It serves up beer, frozen boat-drinks and features nightly entertainment including live music and trivia night.

Can't Get Any Closer to the Water

All rooms here have views of the water. There's water everywhere you look. This is a fisherman's paradise, with a marina and bait shop onsite. The area's well known for its excellent flats fishing.

Quiet with Old Time Florida Key Feel

Sugarloaf Key is about 45-minutes from Key West and its tourists. The vibe here is laid back and guests say they feel like they're taking a step back in time to a quieter, slower pace. And you can't get closer to nature with all the animals and plants in the protected backcountry in the lower keys.

Negative Reviews

Tired Old Hotel

Guests say the hotel could use some updating and few more amenities, like coffee and tea makers in the rooms. Most guests say the hotel is very clean but there are complaints about old mattresses that need to be replaced and worn towels and bedding.

Old-Fashioned Furniture

Guests say the rooms here have a very old-fashioned feel with dated furniture and fixtures. Some consider the decor funky and retro, but others say it feels like Grandma's house, but on the water. Others say they feel like they're staying in the Brady Bunch house.

You'll See Some Bugs

Needless to say, when you're out in nature you'll run into some bugs. Bring some bug repellant and be prepared to see some insects.

Rating Overview

Rating trivago Rating Index based on 1547 reviews across the web
7.8 /10
  • Expedia
    7.8 /10
    7.8 /10
    8.0 /10
  • Other Sources
    8.0 /10
7.8 out of 10 based on 1547 reviews