Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

32 Star Island RoadMontauk11954USA
Show more hotels

About Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

Rich in history, yet recently refreshed for a new era of guests, the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina (MYC) is an award-winning Hamptons hotel ideal for weekend getaways, family vacations and milestone events. We are beautifully located on a private waterfront in the East Hampton hamlet of Montauk, which is on the South Fork of Long Island. Graced by our replica of the historic Montauk Lighthouse, MYC offers an inviting blend of bygone elegance and modern comfort for travelers visiting by air, land or sea.

At the Montauk Yacht Club, we provide a level of privacy which is unique among Montauk hotels and offers vacationers a true escape from the pressures of daily life. The resort’s 106 guest rooms, villas and suites feature nautical-inspired décor and private balconies or terraces that overlook the waterfront or our tranquil courtyard.

You’ll also encounter a seemingly endless variety of activities to enjoy during your stay, whether you prefer long days on the water or relaxing on dry land. Greet the morning with a swim in one of our indoor and outdoor pools. Unwind on the private lake beach, or charter a boat from the marina and experience the area’s legendary fishing.


32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY, 11954, USA
Telephone: +1(631)6683100 | Fax: +1(631)6687728 | Official Homepage

Top amenities

  • Free WiFi in lobby
  • Free WiFi in rooms
  • Pool
  • Spa
  • Parking
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar
  • Gym

All amenities

Hotel facilities

  • 24-hour reception
  • Beach / Sun umbrellas
  • Bell service
  • Business center
  • Computer with internet
  • Concierge
  • Conference rooms
  • Convenience store
  • Deck chairs / Lounge chairs
  • Disco / Nightclub
  • Express check-in / out
  • Free WiFi in lobby
  • Gym
  • Hotel bar
  • Hotel safe
  • Indoor swimming pool
  • Laundry service
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Parking garage
  • Pool bar
  • Restaurant
  • Room service
  • Terrace
  • Towels at the pool / beach
  • Wellness center / Spa
  • WiFi in lobby

Room facilities

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathroom with bathtub
  • Bathroom with shower
  • Central heating
  • Desk
  • Electric kettle
  • Free WiFi in rooms
  • Hairdryer
  • Ironing board
  • Refrigerator
  • Room safe
  • Satellite TV
  • Telephone
  • Television
  • WiFi in rooms

Wellness / Spa

  • Beauty salon
  • Body treatments
  • Massage
  • Sauna
  • Whirlpool / Hot tub


  • Accessible parking
  • Accessible paths / hallways
  • Wheelchair accessible

For children

  • Child / Baby crib
  • Childcare / Babysitting

Arrival / Departure

  • Check-in: 16:00
  • Check-out: 11:00

Positive Reviews

Lakefront Delights.

The serene sights and sounds of Lake Montauk display themselves to the senses in all their relaxing glory. Many of Montauk Yacht Club's sumptuously arranged rooms and warmly lit residents' facilities highlight the lake's natural beauty, permitting stunning views of its activity--especially stunning from the private balcony or patio.

Well-Equipped Rooms.

Upon entering the well-appointed sleeping arrangements of this modern resort, warm hues and comfortable furnishings catch the eye in display of elegance. Coupling such an impressive decor, a slew of modern amenities persist throughout the entirety of the en-suite lodgings--some of which include flat-screen televisions and miniature fridges.

Prompt Service.

Those initially arriving at this upscale accommodation house are met by a group of welcoming personalities. Complimentary coffee, tea, and light snacks are displayed to guests approaching reception, soon to follow, staff suggest popular venues and destinations. All other sanctions of personnel uphold synonymous standards of care.

Negative Reviews

Noisy Functions.

Former guests of Montauk Yacht Club have borne discontent over the level of disruptive commotion which is often emitted from the function areas of the resort. Especially so for rooms nearing said function spaces, loud music and general commotion from weddings, parties, and the like may detract from the quality of sleep.

Poor Wi-Fi.

Although Montauk Yacht Club provides residents with complimentary wireless internet access, many have reported facing difficulty when attempting to gain connection from their rooms. Many of the residents' facilities, such as the lobby and bar, permit stronger access, however.

Restaurant Delays.

While the quality and taste of the meals served in Montauk Yacht Club rarely fail to impress, former visitors have voiced their discontent with lengthy wait-times for service. Many have reported waiting an upwards of forty minutes between ordering and consuming.

Rating Overview

Rating trivago Rating Index based on 1280 reviews across the web
8.1 /10
  • Expedia
    8.2 /10
    8.4 /10
  • Other Sources
    7.6 /10
8.1 out of 10 based on 1280 reviews